Every cookie baked on these pans just ... Of the aluminum quarter-sheets I tried — made by Vollrath, Nordic Ware, and Made In — I didn’t notice a major difference in how they cooked.

Nordic Ware makes the most durable sheet pans out ... Besser says they’re the “closest brand to the industrial baking sheets” she used in the kitchen at the beloved Brooklyn restaurant ...

When treated correctly, baking sheets should last a long time: Brands such as Nordic Ware even offer lifetime guarantees for their products. But such warranties can be voided by improper use ...