The best tinted moisturizer is Laura Mercier’s Long Wear Tinted Moisturizer. We spoke to makeup artists about options for oily, dry, and sensitive skin from NARS, Ilia, Ami Colē, and more.

Not to mention, the balms offer a choose-your-own-adventure kind of color payoff. “Tinted lip balm is very buildable, so if you want a more natural, sheer look you can apply one to two layers ...