Cutest Cookies makes custom nut-free cookies for birthdays, weddings, communions, holidays and more for pick-up in New York & New Jersey or shipped to your door

The minimum order is 1 dozen per design. Once you order over 1 dozen any amount of cookies can be ordered. It does not have to be by the dozen. The cookies on the website are shown in …

You can't help but smile when you see these cute pumpkin cookies. Perfect for your Thanksgiving dinner or to give out at classroom parties. Cookie size 4” x 4” Price per cookie: $5.00. …

Sweet little bibs to celebrate the arrival of a special little bundle of joy. Cookie size 4.5" x 3.5"

A first birthday is such a special time. Make the party more memorable with these adorable #1 cookies. Includes personalization with a name up to 8 letters. Cookie size 5" high . Price per …

Cute gingerbread cookies to help you celebrate the holiday season. Cookie size 4.25" x 3.75" Price per cookie: $4.25 (personalization may be extra)

Who can resist these adorable reindeer cookies. Great for teacher gifts and class parties. Cookie size 4" high . Price per cookie: $4.25 (personalization may be extra)

Cutest Cookies makes custom nut-free cookies for birthdays, weddings, communions, holidays and more for pick-up in New York & New Jersey or shipped to your door

Cute coach cookies to celebrate the princess in your life. Can be personalized with a name up to 10 letters. Cookie size 5.5" x 5"

Our all butter cookies taste great in any shape. These cross cookies are the perfect favor for any religious celebration. Cookie size 5 1/4" x 4"